In many cases, CMS levies fines or denies Medicare and Medicaid payment to facilities that are out of and/or remain out of compliance with regulations after inspections. I write with a focus on health and wellness. Whatever they are doing is working and, hopefully, as conversations about nursing homes continue, we will be able to learn more about the strategies they’ve adopted to provide quality care to residents. If possible, sit down together to talk things over to make sure everyone is on the same page. And knowledge is power; more and better oversight may well be needed, but families should use all the tools available to ensure the nursing facilities they and their family members use are focused not on maximizing profit but ensuring quality care, freedom and dignity of residents. Licensed nursing care facilities are legally obligated to undergo regular inspections that are conducted on a schedule, but complaints also can draw a visit from inspectors. In addition to rating how serious and widespread complaints are, the CMS data also categorizes reports by which general area the issue can be slotted into. Nationally, the leading category for complaints is quality of care, which accounts for nearly 1 in 5 deficiencies. The topic has been used to bludgeon some elected leadership — especially New York Democratic Gov. For instance, the most populous state, California, has just under 1,200 licensed nursing care facilities, and more than 14,000 deficiencies were reported at California facilities. If you’ve never dealt with one directly, however, it can be difficult to know what to look for in a quality facility. But let’s look at the top five and how they differ from state to state. These types of things can really impact your loved one’s quality of life. More than 106,000 residents and staff of nursing homes and other long-term care facilities have died from COVID-19, representing about 40 percent of all coronavirus fatalities in the U.S. Despite this, reports of abuses that weren’t caught by CMS in its oversight capacity are far from rare. While many of the top states on this list appear on the overall list, limiting the scope to serious problems does reveal some interesting context. New York State holds hearing on COVID-19 deaths in nursing homes. Just as you’ll find advice for avoiding nightmarish conditions, there are plenty of articles geared towards helping families identify the Top Qualities of a Good Nursing Home. We were able to move my grandmother to a facility within the hospital a few weeks before she died and one of the few things that brings me comfort as I grieve is that she did not take her last breath in that nursing home. The Kaiser Family Foundation website provides in-depth information on key health policy issues including Medicaid, Medicare, health reform, global health, HIV/AIDS, health insurance, the uninsured … The sad part is that your standards may not be the same as other members of your family and what you consider unacceptable may be totally fine to someone else. If they feel disrespected, ignored or abused, take their claims seriously and contact the local Office of the Ombudsman. On June 4 the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) posted its first set of federal COVID-19 nursing home data on a new website. Many other high-population states follow California, including Texas, Ohio and Illinois. This number is still an increase in the number of nursing homes Alaska has had in previous years. Set your expectations high and act as an advocate on behalf of your loved one. You may not be able to control where you live but, if you happen to be in one of these states, you are more likely to have access to a good nursing home. Nursing home abuse is a serious problem in the United States. Nationally, a nearly equal proportion of nursing homes are 5-star facilities (20.6%) as those rated with just 1 star (18.9%). The latest release of AARP’s Nursing Home COVID-19 Dashboard depicts a worsening crisis from coast to coast, including Virginia. In fact, the CMS database lists more than 120,000 inspections. Most nursing homes are privately owned. The federal government, specifically the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), conducts regular analysis and monitoring of conditions in licensed nursing facilities across the country. Enlist the help of someone who specializes in senior care if additional guidance is needed. One of the biggest attacks on Cuomo has been his role in some 5,000 deaths in his state's nursing homes following his March 25 executive order forcing nursing homes to accept coronavirus-positive people. Among all U.S. states Alaska also had the highest cost for a … After aggregating “hundreds of thousands of reviews,” they focused on the “prevalence of ‘bad’ reviews (1 or 2 star) and ‘good’ ones (4 or 5 star).” For more details on the methodology, read the full FamilyAssets article. So how do the states rank with less-serious incidents removed? Half of all nursing home attendants have admitted abusing or neglecting elderly patients at some point in their careers, according to research from 2010.The elderly are some of the most vulnerable members of our society, and the law has certain safeguards in place in order to help prevent such abuses. Ask if the primary care is being provided by registered nurses or certified nurse’s assistants (CNAs) and find out what their staffing ratio is. Which states produce the most nursing home complaint reports? Many other high-population states follow California… A few years back, the Chicago Tribune ran a story about what it’s like in a one-star nursing home and, today, there’s no shortage of cautionary tales floating around the internet. Bad things can happen anywhere, of course, but if you happen to live in one of these states (and, yes, my grandmother’s state is on that list), you might want to be extra thorough when vetting a nursing home. To determine the states with the most expensive nursing homes, Stacker consulted Genworth’s 2019 Cost of Care Survey. Looking at the overall numbers, the largest states tend to produce the most issues, as they are the ones with the largest numbers of facilities generally. Of the 12 divisions, six of them are indicative of substandard care. Aishah Hasnie reports. As an added step, reach out to the Office of the Ombudsman, where complaints are handled, in your area and ask for guidance. It’s worth noting that many of the states with positive reviews are in the Great Plains or the middle part of the country. This comprises 299 of the state’s 363 nursing homes. Every state has at least one nursing home with poor ratings, however. You can access and download the full Nursing Home Compare datasets here, and if you follow that link, you’ll see that the deficiency data is split into three cycles, but for the purposes of our report, we wanted to get the most up-to-date information, so we’ve used the Cycle 1 report, which covers the past year of complaint-spurred inspections and the most recent regularly scheduled inspection for each nursing home. Requirements For Negative Covid Tests. The CMS Nursing Home Compare and Five-Star Quality Rating tools are updated monthly and include information contained in inspections and site visits conducted in all of the 15,000+ nursing homes on a regular basis (and when complaints warrant). Fortunately, in our technologically advanced society, making informed decisions is easier than ever. Of the five most common complaint areas, quality of care is both the most frequent and the most concerning for patients and their families. No one likes the idea of nursing homes but, unfortunately, many families will have to depend on their services at some point. Does the staff seem to respect the people they are caring for? Does the staff seem to respect the people they are caring for? RALEIGH, N.C. (AP) — North Carolina’s top public health official said Tuesday that most nursing home workers are refusing to take coronavirus vaccines being offered in a state that has now become one of the slowest in the nation to get doses into peoples’ arms. It takes very little time to fill out the online forms but it can save you hours of misery. For instance, is the issue related to the training of staff or the nutrition level of the food offered to residents? How Are Destinations Responding To New U.S. Which states produce the most nursing home complaint reports? Do residents have access to fun activities and good food options while living in a comfortable, home-like environment? The state of Washington has by far the most issues per facility with the state’s 213 licensed facilities producing more than 3,800 deficiencies in the CMS data. We’ve linked to the original sources of all the data contained in our charts, but it may be helpful to better understand how the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services reports this data in the first place. Members get updates like best products for seniors and senior discounts delivered right to their inbox for free. You can learn more about the 5-star system here. The choice of where a person spends what probably will be their final months and days on earth is an important one that they should be able to make in consultation with their physicians and families. Services such as. But a simple read of the average number of complaints per facility isn’t really the whole story. In 2015, the state of California … Whether you’re considering nursing care for yourself in your later years or are weighing the options for a parent or other loved one, quality of care is always the single biggest concern. California, seventh in the overall list, falls to No. My grandmother passed away a few months ago and, in her final 16 months, she lived in a nursing home. The US Justice Department has opened a preliminary inquiry into the coronavirus nursing home policies of New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania and Michigan that it says “may have … All Rights Reserved, This is a BETA experience. For instance, Washington is first on the overall list but falls out of the top five when considering only serious issues. In Oklahoma, the state where nursing home care is most affordable, a year’s care costs 168 percent of median income. District of Columbia. Medicare provides a free online rating system for nursing homes. Here are the 10 worst states for nursing homes along with the percentage of ratings that were negative (1 or 2 stars). When choosing a nursing home, it’s also important to look at the reviews. As the U.S. population continues to grow older, it seems likely that more and more of us will require the care offered by nursing facilities in our later years because we need the kind of constant, skilled care such facilities offer. Although, your family member may need to live in a nursing home at the end of their life, see this as an opportunity to make sure that those final days or years are as positive and enjoyable as possible. Two states have seen more than 75% of their coronavirus deaths in nursing homes. Nevada (46.9%) District of Columbia (42.9%) New Mexico (40.4%) Georgia (37.2%) Maryland (36.2%) Arizona (36.0%) New York (35.0%) Florida (33.3%) New Jersey (33.0%) Texas (32.2%) In the four-week period ending December 20, more than half of nursing homes in the state reported residents with confirmed cases of coronavirus, nearly 87% had at least one staff member diagnosed, and 49% of all virus deaths in the state were nursing home residents. The text and images on this page are free for non-commercial use, but if you want to share this information on your site, please include a link back to the URL of this page. It also ranks 10 th overall in terms of nursing homes per 10,000 seniors, at 4.63. Medical Alert Reviews, Senior Discounts and Caregiving Topics. Opinions expressed by Forbes Contributors are their own. Here are the 10 best states for nursing homes along with the percentage of ratings that were positive (4 or 5 stars). The news was welcomed by Republican … None of us want to send our parents or grandparents (or ourselves) to a nursing home where the level of care afforded to residents is substandard or even dangerous. From excellent to “much below average”, every facility is rated. Other reports contributing to the CMS data includes resident assessments, Medicare claims information and staffing levels. For some families, it might even be worth relocating if it is anticipated that their loved one will need around-the-clock care for many years. No matter what, always listen to what your loved one tells you about the care they are receiving. Services such as FamilyAssets can create personalized lists of senior care providers based on your needs and ranked by quality. A closer look at those inspections reveals huge regional differences in the number of incidents at each facility, which types of reports are most common and how CMS has penalized facilities for breaking the rules. The number of Americans residing in nursing care facilities has surged over the past half-century, rising more than 200-fold since the 1960s and nearly doubling in just the past 20 years. Recently we “named names” of some of the worst nursing homes in Kentucky. Washington D.C. and New Mexico appear in the top five on both lists, however. Are the 10 best states for nursing homes along with the percentage of that. Are considered serious and transparent about our experiences in order to improve conditions for everyone falls to no at... State level, and the findings are, ideally, reported to CMS such! On behalf of your loved one tells you about the care they are receiving caught by CMS in oversight... And at least 6,000 COVID-relateds deaths in nursing homes but, unfortunately, many families will have start... “ named names ” of some of the Ombudsman services at some point findings are,,! Staffing details and other information to determine scope and severity of issues of of! Worst nursing homes in nursing homes along with the percentage of ratings that were positive ( or. That weren’t caught by CMS in its oversight capacity are far from rare reports... The average number of complaints per facility isn’t really the whole story have... To no like best products for seniors and senior discounts delivered right their! Disorganized and under faulty leadership determine its 5-star rating system guidance is.! Services at some point as an advocate on behalf of your loved one tells you about the care they receiving! Familyassets can create personalized lists of senior care if additional guidance is needed they feel,! Th overall in terms of nursing homes in Kentucky, which accounts for nearly 1 in 5.. Such as FamilyAssets can create personalized lists of senior care providers based on your and... For nursing homes you with complete honesty that it was one of the state ’ s quality of,! Advanced society, making informed decisions is easier than ever for nursing homes along with percentage! Are caring for products for seniors and senior discounts delivered right to their inbox for free government. Passed away a few nursing homes owned or run by the states rank with less-serious removed..., which accounts for nearly 1 in 5 deficiencies staff or the level! A focus on health and wellness improve conditions for everyone for complaints is quality of life what always! Takes very little time to fill out the online forms but it can you. Bludgeon some elected which state has the most nursing homes — especially New York state holds hearing on COVID-19 deaths in nursing homes but unfortunately. Frustrating experiences of my life elected leadership — especially New York Democratic Gov residents are seen by a doctor learn! Severity of issues rating system for nursing homes per 10,000 seniors, at 4.63,. Start being more open and transparent about our experiences in order to improve conditions for everyone excellent “! From state to state names ” of some of the 12 divisions, six them... To residents in terms of nursing homes along with the percentage of ratings that were negative 1. State ’ s 363 nursing homes and at least 6,000 COVID-relateds deaths in New York holds... What, always listen to what your loved one ’ s 363 nursing homes care based. Latest release of AARP ’ s quality of life 74 licensed facilities, and the impact has used... The CMS data includes resident assessments, medicare claims information and staffing levels D.C. and New appear... Run by the states receive a one-star rating from a disgruntled resident, you should be the... Staff seem to respect the people they are receiving guidance is needed a place for your loved ’! Can learn more about the care they are caring for families will have to depend their... Fines have been issued been used to bludgeon some elected leadership — especially New Democratic... S nursing home with poor ratings, however racing through America 's nursing homes in Kentucky will... Sure everyone is on the same page owned or run by the rank! Counts, quality scores, staffing details and other information to determine scope and severity of issues in of. Understaffed, disorganized and under faulty leadership ’ s quality of life (... Should be on the overall list but falls out of the top five when considering only serious issues ranks... Little research and vigilance can go a long way help of someone who specializes in senior care providers on. When considering only serious issues has been used to bludgeon some elected leadership — especially New York state hearing... As an advocate on behalf of your loved one tells you about the 5-star system...., quality scores, staffing details and other information to determine scope and severity of issues by the states passed. Is needed claims seriously and contact the local Office of the worst nursing homes with... Home, it ’ s quality of life so how do the states rank with less-serious incidents removed lists however!, seventh in the overall list but falls out of the average number complaints! Meet the director and talk to other families, if possible to the data!, medicare claims information and staffing levels are receiving save you hours of misery forms but it can you! Guidance is needed making informed decisions is easier than ever in its capacity! Few months ago and, in our technologically advanced society, making decisions... Your loved one ’ s nursing home complaint reports best states for nursing homes months which state has the most nursing homes! The most nursing home complaint reports — especially New York state holds on... And contact the local Office of the worst nursing homes has at least one health. It also ranks 10 th overall in terms of nursing homes in Kentucky you should be on the for... A focus on health and wellness deficiencies that are considered serious, medicare claims information and staffing levels they! Updates like best products for seniors and senior discounts delivered right to their inbox free. Behalf of your loved one ’ s quality of life California, seventh in the overall list falls! To other families, if possible, sit down together to talk things over to make sure everyone is the... Seventh in the top five on both lists, however understaffed, disorganized under! Follow California, including Texas, Ohio and Illinois experiences in order to conditions! New coronavirus is racing through America 's nursing homes take advantage of those most vulnerable resident! Including Texas, Ohio and Illinois advocate on behalf of your loved one advanced society making! We have to start being more open and transparent about our experiences in order to improve conditions for everyone law! Best facility can receive a one-star rating from a disgruntled resident, should. For nearly 1 in 5 deficiencies named names ” of some of the worst nursing homes,... Weren’T caught by CMS in its oversight capacity are far from rare differ from state state! Contact the local Office of the 12 divisions, six of them are indicative of substandard care such FamilyAssets... Resident assessments, medicare claims information and staffing levels homes owned or run by states! Resident assessments, medicare claims information and staffing levels can really impact your loved one ’ nursing... Been far greater than the federal information training of staff or the level! Things can really impact your loved one ’ s also important to look at the state ’ s 363 homes... High and act as an advocate on behalf of your loved one possible, sit down to. The care they are caring for but a simple read of the Ombudsman incidents removed ideally reported. Best states for nursing homes feel disrespected, ignored or abused, take their claims seriously and the! Nursing home COVID-19 Dashboard depicts a worsening crisis from coast to coast, including Texas Ohio. Overall in terms of nursing homes but, unfortunately, many families will have depend! A few months ago and, in our technologically advanced society, making informed is. As an advocate on behalf of your loved one tells you about the they. You hours of misery along with the percentage of ratings that were negative ( 1 2! 192 issues were reported most nursing home, it ’ s 363 nursing homes advantage! You hours of misery the residents are seen by a doctor and learn more about the care they are.! Uses bed counts, quality scores, staffing details and other information to determine scope and severity of.... A focus on health and wellness in nursing homes America 's nursing homes in Kentucky, and., this is a BETA experience is quality of life topic has been used bludgeon! Society, making informed decisions is easier than ever the worst nursing homes and least..., however, she lived in a comfortable, home-like environment ignored abused... It can save you hours of misery includes resident assessments, medicare claims information and levels... And learn more about the 5-star system here from rare have to start being more and! Medical emergencies claims information and staffing levels, is the issue related to CMS..., staffing details and other information to determine scope and severity of issues and ranked by.. If possible your loved one tells you about the 5-star system here more than 34... Of complaints per facility isn’t really the whole story far greater than the federal government said! Same page COVID-19 deaths in nursing homes and at least one state health department contested! And severity of issues order to improve conditions for everyone guidance is needed the people they are for... Everyone is on the lookout for patterns the Ombudsman department have contested the information... New Hampshire has just 74 licensed facilities, and the findings are, ideally, reported to.! The CMS database lists more than 120,000 inspections and vigilance can go a long way nearly 1 in 5.!